使用冷水組合式照護是否能降低加護病房病人口渴程度Effect of cold water with bundle care on thirst patients in adult intensive care unit.

2382 7 310         DOI:doi.org/10.30131/TWNA_EBHC_Library.DB_2021010006B/Text

2021-05-24 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

林佳瑩* 吳虹諗 王怡婷

文章類別

B 類:實證健康照護應用

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

胸腔暨重症加護醫學 (Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine)  

治療/介入措施

其他(Others) -

專長類別

心血管及胸腔

中文關鍵詞

#加護病房、口渴、組合式照護、冷水

英文關鍵詞

#Intensive care unit # thirst # Buddle care # cold water

機構名稱

長庚醫療財團法人林口長庚紀念醫院

申請單位

第二內科加護病房

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
探討使用冷水組合式照護是否能降低成人加護病房病人口渴程度?PICO-P:成人加護病房病患、I:冷水組合式照護、O:口渴程度。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
文獻搜尋的資料庫包含:Cochrane、PubMed、Embase。關鍵字包含:P(ICU、Intensive Care Units、Critical Care)、I(Patient Care Bundles、Intervention*、bundle*、cold water、Spray*、lip moisturizer*、moisturizer*、menthol)、O(Thirst、Thirst Distress、Thirst Intensity、Thirst relief*、Numeric rating scales);運用PubMed建立MeSH term及同義字,並且考量字型變化及單複數故運用截斷字truncation(*),並使用布林邏輯原則,將關鍵字、同義字及MeSH term用OR聯集,再將P、I、O用AND交集,並且也從文獻中交叉比對關鍵字,進而新增關鍵字,以增加搜尋廣度,以多種組合方式來搜尋文獻,不限定發表文獻語言。
文獻的品質評讀與結果:
搜尋結果:文獻資料庫共13篇,其中扣除重複、非RCT、非SR 研究、研究設計方法不符合PICO、等級低文獻後,共評讀1篇,採用2020年版的CASP作為評讀工具。
證據之臨床應用:
證據之臨床應用-運用實證知識轉譯之七步驟進行改善,以專案方式進行。收案期間自2020年10月01日至2020年11月15日,對象為北部某醫學中心加護病房的病人,以隨機前後對照實驗方式進行,介入措施為組合式模組:使用3.5~4.1°C冷水海綿棒擦拭口腔,冷水噴霧瓶噴向口咽、舌頭部位及薄荷保濕護脣膏塗抹嘴唇的組合式照護。
成效評值:
措施介入自2020年10月01日至11月15日,共收案9人,其口渴程度數字量表(NRS)由介入前6.10分下降至介入後3.16分,口渴痛苦的平均分數由介入前5.66分下降至介入後2.83分,此外,計算病人在介入措施後,平均再次表示口渴時間約54分鐘。故可將措施與常規的每小時巡視作業相結合,不會增加額外的照護負擔。顯示使用組合式模組照護對於加護病房病人的口渴感受程度以及口渴痛苦的程度具有緩解效果。
結論與建議:
以多元介入措施:常規給予冷水海綿棒濕潤口腔、冷水噴霧及塗抹薄荷保濕護脣膏作為組合,十分簡單便利,而且可以輕鬆應用在繁忙的重症單位,與每小時的照護處置做結合,計算成本效益:口腔海綿棒一支新台幣3元,薄荷保濕護唇膏一支新台幣100元,噴霧瓶新台幣10元,整體總計不到台幣200元,是一項容易達到的安全且經濟實惠之措施,對病人無使用藥物副作用之疑慮,無特殊安全問題,而從9位收案對象中亦有4位是意識清楚之插管病人,顯示措施亦可應用於放置氣管內管病人,故未來會持續追蹤在氣管內管留置病人之效益,希望能以此次經驗分享,提供多元的實證應用,提升重症照護品質。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
Effect of cold water with bundle care on thirst patients in adult intensive care units. PICO-P: adult intensive care unit, I: patient care bundles, O: thirst
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
Through Boolean logic, the study keywords and synonyms of PICO were searched on Cochrane library, Embase, PubMed and CEPS. Keywords include: P(ICU, Intensive Care Units, Critical Care), I(Patient Care Bundles, Intervention*, bundle*, cold water, Spray*, lip moisturizer*, moisturizer*, menthol), O(Thirst, Thirst, Distress, Thirst Intensity, Thirst relief*, Numeric rating scales); and MeSH terms and truncation are combined with OR, and P, I, and O are combined with AND to search for documents in multiple combinations.
Critical Appraisal:
Totally 13 literatures were obtained. After screening, one randomized controlled trial study was selected. These one research evidences were critically appraised for validity, importance, and practicability through the appraising tool of CASP in the version of 2020.
Clinical Application of Evidence:
Using 7 steps of empirical knowledge translation to improve the question. The acceptance period is from October 1, 2020 to November 15, 2020. The subjects are patients in the intensive care unit of a northern medical center. Randomized pre-test/post-test design are conducted. Intervention measures are modular modules: use 3.5~4.1° C The combined care of cold water cotton sticks to wipe the mouth, cold water spray bottle sprayed to the oropharynx, tongue area, and menthol lip moisturizer.
Evaluation of Effectiveness:
From October 01 to November 15, 2020, 9 cases were admitted. Thirst intensity scale (on a numeric rating scale [NRS] of 1-10), dropped from 6.10 before intervention to 3.16 after intervention. The average score of thirst distress increased from before the intervention, 5.66 dropped to 2.83 after the intervention. In addition, after the intervention, the average time for patients to express thirst again was about 54 minutes. The intervention can be combined with regular hourly inspections without adding extra care burden, It shows that the use of bundle care has a relief effect on the degree of thirst and the degree of thirst distress of patients in the intensive care unit.
Conclusions and Recommendations:
Multiple intervention measures: routinely give cold water sponge sticks to moisten the mouth, cold water spray and apply mint moisturizing lip balm as a combination, which is very simple and convenient, and can be easily applied to reduce critically ill units, combined with hourly care and treatment, to calculate cost-effectiveness: An oral sponge swab is 3 yuan, a mint moisturizing lip balm is NT$ 100 , and a spray bottle is NT$10. The total total is less than NT$200. It is an easy-to-reach safe and economical measure that does not use drugs indirectly. There are no special safety issues, and 4 of the 9 cases are clearly conscious intubation of patients, showing measures can be applied to patients of endotracheal tube intubation, so we will continue to track patients of endotracheal tube intubation in the future. I hope to use this experience sharing to provide multiple empirical applications to improve the quality of critical care.