音樂治療是否能降低手術病人術前焦慮情形?Can music therapy reduce preoperative anxiety in surgical patients?

2429 4 273         DOI:doi.org/10.30131/TWNA_EBHC_Library.DB_2022030014B/Text

2022-09-15 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

陶宣佑 陳文鈴 徐雯娟*

文章類別

B 類:實證健康照護應用

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

其他 (other)  

治療/介入措施

臨床護理技術相關措施(Clinical Nursing Skills and Techniques) - 音樂治療

專長類別

急重症暨手術護理

中文關鍵詞

#術前焦慮 #音樂治療

英文關鍵詞

#pre-operative anxiety # music therapy

機構名稱

長庚醫療財團法人林口長庚紀念醫院

申請單位

護理部

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
探討使用音樂治療是否能降低手術病人術前焦慮情形?PICO- P:手術前病人、I:音樂治療、C:常規照護、O:術前焦慮情形。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
(一) 文獻搜尋資料庫包含:Cochrane library、PubMed、Embase、CEPS中文電子期刊資料庫。 (二) 關鍵字包含:依所設立的PICO利用PubMed建立MeSH term及尋找同義字,並使用切截字*,依照布林邏輯原則,將關鍵字、同義字及MeSH term用OR聯集,再將P、I、O用AND交集組合方式來搜尋文獻,並限縮搜尋條件為10年內、可瀏覽全文、語言為中、英文、研究類型為隨機對照試驗(Randomized controlled trial, RCT)、系統性文獻回顧(Systematic review, SR)或統合分析(meta-analysis)等類型文章。
文獻的品質評讀與結果:
搜尋文獻結果共有80篇,排除重複、與PICO不符合之文獻、屬於個案報告之文獻、無法瀏覽全文之文獻,並進一步瀏覽後排除研究對象僅限女性之文章,共納入3篇文章,分別為1篇SR及2篇RCT之文章進行評析,採用2020年版的CASP作為評讀工具,以及使用Oxford CEBM(2011)進行證據等級分類。
證據之臨床應用:
運用實證知識轉譯之七步驟進行改善,推行同時進行結果分析,收案期間為2022年1月3日至2022年1月10日,採立意取樣,針對北部某醫學中心整形外科住院預接受手術之病人進行收案,將病人隨機分成實驗組(聆聽音樂組)及對照組(常規照護組),介入措施為音樂治療,讓收案對象於單獨、安靜的協談室內,實驗組依照其喜好自古典、輕音樂、藏族音樂、中文流行音樂、英文流行音樂等六種類型中選擇一種音樂戴耳機聆聽,介入時間為30分鐘,音樂設定為低音、節奏慢、60-80bpm。
成效評值:
本次共收案20位病人,焦慮程度依據視覺類比焦慮量表(VAS-A)測得實驗組的焦慮程度分數由4.00±2.16分下降至1.80±2.04分,對照組焦慮程度分數由3.70±1.94分上升至4.10±2.13分,且達統計上之顯著差異(P=.024),顯示音樂介入後可改善手術病人術前焦慮程度。
結論與建議:
音樂治療可降低手術病人術前焦慮程度,護理人員僅須在介入前後給予病人耳機,所耗費時間不超過3分鐘,不至影響臨床治療,且音樂介入屬於無侵入性、病人接受度高、低成本皆為可持續推行之優勢,此外,建議未來應用上可增加具本土性之相關曲目如:台語、客語等音樂種類,將更符合本地文化背景。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
To explore whether the use of music therapy can reduce preoperative anxiety in surgical patients? PICO- P:Pre-operative patient、I:Music therapy、C:Routine care、O:Pre-operative anxiety.
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
1. Literature search databases included: Cochrane library, PubMed, Embase, CEPS Chinese Electronic Journal Database. 2. Keywords included: According to the established PICO standard, we used PubMed to establish MeSH term and look for synonyms and used truncation*. According to the principle of Boolean logic, combined keywords, synonyms and MeSH terms with OR. Then, P, I, and O were combined by AND to search for literature, and the search conditions were limited to within 10 years, full text were browsed, the language was Chinese and English, the research type was randomized controlled trial (RCT), systematic review (SR) or meta-analysis.
Critical Appraisal:
A total of 80 articles were searched, including excluding duplicates, articles not in line with PICO, articles belonging to case reports, articles that could not be viewed in full text, after further browsing, the articles whose subjects are only women are excluded, and a total of 3 articles were included, 1 SR and 2 RCTs were then evaluated and analyzed. The 2020 version of the CASP was used as a review tool, and the Oxford CEBM (2011) was used for the classification of evidence levels.
Clinical Application of Evidence:
Used the seven steps of empirical knowledge translation for improvement as well as implement simultaneous results analysis. The purposive sampling research was used from January 3, 2022 to January 10, 2022. For the patients who received pre-operative surgery in the plastic surgery department of a northern medical center, the patients were randomly divided into the experimental group (listening to music group) and the control group (routine care group). The intervention measure was music therapy. The subjects were placed in a separate and quiet consultation room. The experimental group chose one type of music from the six types of classical music, light music, Tibetan music, Chinese pop music, and English pop music according to their preferences and listened to them with headphones. The intervention time was 30 minutes, and the music was set to bass, slow tempo, 60-80bpm.
Evaluation of Effectiveness:
A total of 20 patients were included in this study. The anxiety level measured by the Visual Analogy Anxiety Scale (VAS-A) decreased from 4.00±2.16 to 1.80±2.04 in the experimental group and increased from 3.70±1.94 to 4.10±2.13 in the control group reaching significant difference (p = 0.24), indicating that music intervention can improve the preoperative anxiety of surgical patients.
Conclusions and Recommendations:
Music therapy reduces preoperative anxiety in surgical patients. Nursing staff only need to give patients earphones before and after the intervention, which takes no more than 3 minutes and will not affect clinical treatment. Music intervention is non-invasive, highly acceptable to patients, and low-cost, all of which are the advantages of sustainable implementation. In addition, it is suggested to add relevant local tracks in future applications, such as Taiwanese, Hakka and other music types, which will be more in line with the local cultural background