使用離床警報是否能預防住院病人跌倒發生Can use the Bed-Exit alarm system prevent the inpatient fall down

2604 3 293         DOI:doi.org/10.30131/TWNA_EBHC_Library.DB_2021010013B/Text

2021-06-18 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

王秋琴 廖雪妃 李宜柔 林美惠 余文彬*

文章類別

B 類:實證健康照護應用

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

腫瘤醫學 (Oncology)  

治療/介入措施

臨床護理技術相關措施(Clinical Nursing Skills and Techniques) - 防跌措施

專長類別

腫瘤及安寧/緩和

中文關鍵詞

#跌倒、離床警報

英文關鍵詞

#Falls # Bed-Exit alarm

機構名稱

長庚醫療財團法人基隆長庚紀念醫院

申請單位

血液腫瘤科

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
形成臨床提問-探討使用離床警示是否可有效預防住院病人跌倒發生?P:住院病人、I:使用離床警報、C:常規照護、O:跌倒發生率。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
(一)文獻搜尋資料庫包含:PubMed、CEPS、Cochrane、Embase、Clinicalkey (二)關鍵字包含:P(inpatient、住院病人)、I(Sensor、Bed exit alarm、Bed alarm、Technology、Monitoring、Telemedicine、Alarms、離床感知器、離床警報)、C(usual care、常規照護)、O(Fall prevention、Reduce falls、Accident Prevention/instrumentation、Accidental Falls/prevention & control、跌倒發生率),關鍵字和PICO符合,PICO關鍵字順序:P&I→O→C,Combine text words/keywords/MeSH term搜尋,使用布林字元”OR,AND,NOT”,篩選語言為中英文。
文獻的品質評讀與結果:
文獻的品質評讀-搜尋結果:中英文文獻資料庫共43篇,其中排除重複、使用其他介入措施、標題不符合文獻、介入組非感應床墊、無對照組後、共評讀3篇,採用2018年CASP作為評讀工具。
證據之臨床應用:
證據之臨床應用-運用實證知識轉譯之7步驟進行改善,推行同時進行結果分析,自2020年1月至2020年8月,於北部某區域教學醫院血液腫瘤科病房,針對符合血腫科病人離床警報使用標準之病人,使用離床警報。
成效評值:
以本院病安通報資料統計結果,於2020年1月至8月此段時間病房符合使用離床警報之個案共計83人,實際使用離床警報個案共67位,使用1,236人日數,其中有10位病人發生跌倒,跌倒發生率為0.81%(10/1,236),但於床邊跌倒發生事件0件(0%)。
結論與建議:
此篇旨探討使用離床警報是否可有效預防住院病人跌倒發生?透過實證查詢及臨床應用,形成PICO後利用實證醫學策略,搜尋並篩選相關文獻,並經嚴格評析3篇文獻,使用離床警報目前的證據顯示無法有效預防住院病人跌倒發生。因考量病人跌倒後對醫療保健系統造成的負擔,故將其應用在臨床上。推動結果:使用離床警報跌倒發生率0.81%(10/1,236),單位跌倒發生率為0.07%(13/17,102),在使用離床警報後跌倒發生率雖未見顯著成效,但床邊發生跌倒情形0件,床邊警報主要作用為即時發現離床能即時提供協助,此結果可有效防範床邊跌倒事件發生。目前推動之困難在於警報響起時護理師因作業忙碌無法及時到達病人單位及家屬或病人拒絕安裝,應加強病人與家屬對離床警報之認識,達到共同防跌的目標,並建議若能將系統架接到工作車、紅燈系統或家屬的手機,能更發揮其防範功能,希望透過此實證的初步推動結果,讓更多人願意參與相關研究,提供病人更安全、更全面有效的照護設備。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
Build up a clinical question: explore that use the Bed-Exit alarm system could show result to prevent the inpatient fall down. PICO - P: inpation ; I:use the Bed-Exit Sensor ; C:usual care ; O:rate of falls.
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
The literature searching database includes PubMed,CEPS,Cochrane, Embase, Clinicalkey Keywords are includes as follows: P (Inpatient), I(Sensor, Bed exit alarm, Bed alarm, Technology, Monitoring, Telemedicine, Alarms), C(Usual care), O(Fall prevention, Reduce falls, Accident Prevention/instrumentation, Accidental Falls/prevention & control,rate of falls),Keywords is corresponding with PICO , and the sequence of PICO keywords: ” P&I→O→C”; combine text words/keywords/MeSH term searching with Boolean characters “OR, AND, NOT ” ; the languages selected are Chinese and English.
Critical Appraisal:
Qualified critical appraisal of literature- the searching results: there are total 43 articles found in Chinese and English literature databases; by deducting and removing the literature with issue of duplicate, use other intervention, the title isn’t accordance the article, the test group isn’t used the sensor bed and no control group, a total 3 articles of literature are being appraised ,with the appraising tool of CASP in the version of 2018.
Clinical Application of Evidence:
Use the 7 steps empirical knowledge translation to improve, implement and analyze the results at the same time, during the study period, from January 1, 2020 to August 31, 2020; performed in the Oncology ward of a regional teaching hospital in the North, it is aimed at the standard patients who correspond with Oncology’s use the Bed-Exit alarm.
Evaluation of Effectiveness:
According to the data from the Patient-Safe Bulletin of this hospital, the period from January 1, 2020 to August 31, 2020 the patients who agree used the Bed-Exit alarm system total 83 persons, make use of the Bed-Exit alarm system patient are 67 actually, total 1,236 patients used it per day, include 10 patients fell, the rate of falls was 0.81%(10/1,236), it was 0 event of fall at bedside.
Conclusions and Recommendations:
This article explores that use the Bed-Exit alarm system could prevent the inpatient fall down effectively. Based on the empirical inquiry and clinical application, PICO is formed to use the empirical medical strategies to search and screen the relevant literature, and strictly evaluate 3 literatures. The evidence show that use the Bed-Exit alarm system is not effective prevent the inpatient fall down, but consider if patient falls may cause the burden to the Healthcare system so apply it in clinical. Applicable result: the rate of falls was 0.81%(10/1,236),the rate of falls in the Oncology Ward is 0.07%(13/17,102). After use the Bed-Exit alarm system. Although that is not obvious effect after use the Bed-Exit alarm system, however it was 0 event of fall at bedside; the bed side alarm main function is immediate find and prevention then applying help, maybe this main function can effect prevent the event of bedside falls. Now difficult situation is that the nurses too busy to immediate reach the bedside when the alarm ringing, and the family or the patient reject install this system. We should strengthen the patient and the family know the Bed-Exit alarm system to attain the goal of prevention falls together. Suggestion that could express the prevention function if make the system connect with the nursing’s cart, nursing’s alarm system and the family’s mobile. Hope that empirical the Evidence-based result let more participant would like to join the research, afford the patient better and safer care equipment.