接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後病人執行手部及足部按摩是否能降低術後傷口疼痛?Efficacy of Hand and Foot Massage in Pain Management Following nephrectomy (abdominal surgery)

979 3 157         DOI:doi.org/10.30131/TWNA_EBHC_Library.DB_2021110002B/Text

2022-08-05 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

洪子淇* 郭懿靜 張瀞文 陳日慧 柯幸芳 陳美菊

文章類別

B 類:實證健康照護應用

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

一般外科醫學 (General Surgery)  

治療/介入措施

臨床護理技術相關措施(Clinical Nursing Skills and Techniques) - 手部、足部按摩

專長類別

急重症暨手術護理

中文關鍵詞

#腹部手術 #手足部按摩 #術後疼痛

英文關鍵詞

#Abdominal Surgery #Hand Massage #Foot Massage #Postoperative Pain

機構名稱

長庚醫療財團法人高雄長庚紀念醫院

申請單位

護理部

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
形成臨床提問-接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後病人執行手部及足部按摩是否能降低術後傷口疼痛? P:腹部手術後、I:手部、足部按摩、C:常規護理、O:術後傷口疼痛。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
(一)文獻搜尋資料庫包含:Cochrane、Clinicalkey Nursing、PubMed、CEPS(二)關鍵字包含:P(Abdominal Surgery、Nephroectomy)、I(Hand and Foot Massage、Hand Massage、Foot Massage)、O((Decrease Postoperative Pain、Reducing Postoperative Pain);關鍵字和PICO符合PICO關鍵字,Combinate text words/keywords/MeSH term搜尋,使用布林字元"OR, AND, NOT",篩選語言為中英文。
文獻的品質評讀與結果:
文獻的品質評讀搜尋結果:中英文文獻資料庫共253篇,其中排除重複、非RCT及SR研究、研究設計方法不符合PICO、等級低,並刪除文獻後共評讀2篇,文獻之品質採用2020年版的CASP作為評讀工具。
證據之臨床應用:
運用實證知識轉譯之七步驟進行改善,推行中同步進行結果分析。本研究設計為隨機對照實驗研究,研究期間自2021年3月1日至2021年5月20日,選擇南部某醫學中心泌尿科病房,收案期間以手部及足部按摩作為介入措施。
成效評值:
本研究為探討接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後病人執行手部及足部按摩降低術後傷口疼痛之成效。自2021年3月1日至2021年5月20日介入後,共收案20位受試者,經統計分析結果顯示(1)基本資料:實驗組與對照組在年齡及BMI無顯著差異(P >0.05);(2)介入措施實施後經統計分析結果顯示,針對接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後傷口疼痛,藉由執行手部及足部按摩降低術後傷口疼痛指數,實驗組與對照組利用NRS疼痛評估量表差異分數為30分鐘4分、60分鐘3分、90分鐘1分(P <0.001)。
結論與建議:
本研究旨探討接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後病人執行手部及足部按摩是否能降低術後傷口疼痛,透過實證查詢及臨床應用,形成PICO後利用實證醫學策略,搜尋並篩選相關文獻,並經嚴格評析2篇文獻,了解手部、足部按摩確實能降低腹部手術傷口疼痛情況,降低術後傷口疼痛程度;我們將這個結果推論至臨床應用,共收案20位病人,經由我們實證應用在臨床後發現確實,可藉由手部、足部按摩可以改善接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後病人傷口疼痛、此研究結果除能降低腹部手術的疼痛,此介入措施不須費用得考量且沒有副作用,此結果與Kezban & Neziha (2020)及Bilsev & Serdar (2020)相同,因此將此結果運用於接受腎臟切除(腹部手術)術後病人的照護。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
Clinical question formation-the purpose is to explore whether the efficacy of hand and foot massage in pain management following nephrectomy (abdominal surgery) . PICO-P: after Nephrectomy (abdominal surgery), I: Hand and foot massage, C:Daily care, O: Postoperative wound pain.
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
(1)The literature search database includes: Cochrane, Clinicalkey Nursing, PubMed, and CEPS. (2)The keywords include: P (Abdominal Surgery,Nephroectomy), I (Hand and Foot Massage,Hand Massage,Foot Massage), O (Decrease Postoperative Pain,Reducing Postoperative Pain). The keywords and PICO conform to the PICO keyword sequence: I & P O C, Combinet text words / keywords / MeSH term search. Boolean characters "OR, AND, NOT" are used, and the screening language is Chinese and English.
Critical Appraisal:
Quality evaluation of literature-the search results: there are a total of 253 articles in the Chinese and English literature database. Wherein, after deducting the duplicates, non-RCT, non-SR research, research design methods that do not meet PICO, and low grades, after excluding and deleting the literature, a total of 2 articles are evaluated, using the 2020 version of CASP as the evaluation tool.
Clinical Application of Evidence:
Clinical application of evidence-using the 7 steps of empirical knowledge transformation, while improving, implementing and analyzing the results. The study was designed as a randomized controlled experimental study. During the study period, from March 1, 2021 toMay 20, 2021, a ward of a certain southern regional medical center was selected, and hand and foot massage was used as interventional measures during the admission period.
Evaluation of Effectiveness:
Exploring the effectiveness of hand and foot massage in pain management after nephrectomy (abdominal surgery) through statistical analysis. After the intervention from March 1, 2021 to May 20, 2021, among the 20 patients admitted to treatment, statistically verified, (1) Basic information: There is no difference in age and BMI between the two groups, P value (>0.05). (2) After the intervention measures are implemented, the statistical test results show that for patients with postoperative wound pain after nephrectomy (abdominal surgery), hand and foot massage can effectively reduce the postoperative wound pain index. The control group uses the NRS pain assessment scale, 30 Minute 4 minutes, 60 minutes 3 minutes, 90 minutes 1 minute, P value (<.001).
Conclusions and Recommendations:
The purpose of this article is to explore whether efficacy of hand and foot massage in pain management following nephrectomy (abdominal surgery).Based on the empirical inquiry and clinical application, PICO is formed to use the empirical medical strategies to search and screen the relevant literature, and strictly evaluate 2 literatures.It is understood that the hand and foot massage can indeed reduce abdominal surgery wound pain and reduce postoperative wound pain.We have extended this answer to the clinical applications. Although only 20 patients were admitted,through our empirical application, we found that the hand and foot massage can improve the wound pain of patients undergoing nephrectomy (abdominal surgery). This result is consistent with Kezban & Neziha (2020) and Bilsev & Serdar (2020).In the hope of benefiting more patients after nephrectomy (abdominal surgery), the quality of the care can be upgraded.