耳穴貼壓減緩頸椎術後肩頸疼痛程度Auricular point acupressure relieve postoperative shoulder and neck pain in patient with cervical spine surgery

1228 1 199         DOI:doi.org/10.30131/TWNA_EBHC_Library.DB_2021080017B/Text

2022-05-06 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

邱筠涵* 王昭慧

文章類別

B 類:實證健康照護應用

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

神經醫學 (Neurology)  

治療/介入措施

其他(Others) - 耳穴貼壓

專長類別

傳統與輔助醫療

中文關鍵詞

#頸椎術後 #耳穴貼壓 #肩頸疼痛

英文關鍵詞

#Cervical spine surgery # Auricular point acupressure # Neck pain # Shoulder pain  

機構名稱

長庚醫療財團法人林口長庚紀念醫院

申請單位

腦神經外科

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
耳穴貼壓是否可以減緩頸椎手術病人術後肩頸疼痛?。PICO-P:頸椎手術病人、I:耳穴貼壓、C:常規治療、O:肩頸肌肉的疼痛。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
透過PICO建立關鍵字及同義字,研究對象(P)為頸椎手術病人(Cervical spine surgery),介入措施(I)為耳穴貼壓(Auricular point acupressure),對照措施(C)為常規治療,結果評估(O)為肩頸肌肉疼痛(Neck pain or shoulder pain),於Cochrane library、PubMed、Embase、CEPS華藝中文電子期刊資料庫搜尋2021年8月前的文獻,並使用布林邏輯原則,將中英文關鍵字、同義字及MeSH term用OR聯集,再將P、I、O用AND交集,以多種組合方式來搜尋文獻,不限定發表文獻語言。
文獻的品質評讀與結果:
搜尋資料庫共得79篇文獻,其中扣除重複、非RCT、非SR 研究、研究設計方法不符合PICO、等級低文獻後,最後選定一篇隨機對照試驗研究及一篇系統性回顧文獻,以2020年版CASP針對有效性、重要性及應用性評析,並依據2011年Oxford證據分類標準來進行等級分類。
證據之臨床應用:
運用實證知識轉譯之七步驟進行改善,推行同時進行結果分析。研究設計為單一組別前後研究(Single group before-and-after study ),研究期間自2020年09月16日至11月15日,研究地點採方便取樣,選擇北部某醫學中心之三個神經外科病房,介入期間以耳穴貼壓為疼痛緩解處置。
成效評值:
實施期間共收案25人,頸椎手術病人於手術後接受耳穴貼壓介入措施,數字等級量表(NRS)由介入前7.04±1.70分下降至介入後1.20±1.08分,共下降5.84分,顯示耳穴貼壓可以減緩頸椎術後肩頸疼痛程度。
結論與建議:
耳穴貼壓方案無論在頸椎術後肩頸疼痛緩解、不良反應、病人術後肩頸疼痛之抱怨,及臨床經濟效益皆成效良好,故建議全面推行於頸椎手術病人。透過種子教師給予臨床護理師在職教育訓練並回覆示教,以提供病人專業且有效的疼痛緩解處置。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
Bliud up a clinical question: explore if auricular point acupressure can relieve shoulder and neck pain within the patients after cervical spine surgery. PICO-P: patients after cervical spine surgery, I: auricular point acupressure, C: rountine treatment, O: shoulder pain or neck pain.
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
The study keywords of PICO, included: P (Patients with cervical spine sugery), I (Auricular point acupressure), C (Routine treatment) and O (Neck pain or shoulder pain). The above keywords, synonyms and the Mesh terms were combined with “OR” and the P, I, O were combined with “AND” through Boolean logic, and they were searched with multiple combination on Cochrane library, PubMed, Embase and Chinese Electronic Periodical Services (CEPS) of Airiti Library before August 2021, without language limitation of the literatures.
Critical Appraisal:
A total of 79 literatures were obtained in the database. We excluded duplicates, non-RCT, non-SR, low-level evidence, and those research design or methods did not meet PICO. Finally, a randomized controlled trial study and a systematic review of the literature were selected. We evaluated the effectiveness, importance and applicability by CASP in 2020 version; and the classification of evidence level by the Oxford Evidence Classification Standard in 2011 version.
Clinical Application of Evidence:
Using the 7 steps of empirical knowledge translation to improve, implement and analyzing the results was applied in this article. The study was designed as a single group before-and-after study, during September 16 to November 15, 2020, in three neurosurgery wards of a medical center in northern Taiwan. Auricular point acupressure was used as an interventional measure for pain relief.
Evaluation of Effectiveness:
A total of 25 cases were admitted. Patients after cervical spine surgery received interventional measures of auricular point acupressure. The Numerical Rating Scale (NRS) was 7.04±1.70 points before intervention and dropped to 1.20±1.08 points after intervention, with a total decrease of 5.84 points. The results of the study show that the auricular point acupressure is effective in reducing the degree of shoulder and neck pain after cervical spine surgery.
Conclusions and Recommendations:
The auricular point acupressure is effective in relieving shoulder and neck pain, adverse reactions, patients' complaints, and clinical economic benefits after cervical spine surgery. Therefore, it is recommended that it might be fully implemented in patients with cervical spine surgery. Otherwise, we will provide clinical nurses with on-the-job education and training and reply to teaching through the seed teacher, so as to provide patients with professional and effective pain relief treatment.