執行股動脈心導管術後病人予抬高床頭是否會產生血管相關合併症?Is it at high risk of vascular-related complications by raising the head of the bed after patients undergoing femoral artery cardiac catheterization?

1972 7 192         DOI:doi.org/10.30131/TWNA_EBHC_Library.DB_2021070004A/Text

2022-05-10 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

戴子娉* 李宜娟 張育嘉 陳嬿今 鍾佩茹

文章類別

A 類:實證健康照護綜整

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

心血管系統 (Cardiovascular Medicine & Hematology)  

治療/介入措施

其他(Others) - 臨床護理照護相關措施

專長類別

心血管及胸腔

中文關鍵詞

#心導管 #床頭抬高 #血管相關合併症

英文關鍵詞

#cardiac catheterization # bedside elevation # vascular-related complications #vascular complications

機構名稱

國立成功大學醫學院附設醫院

申請單位

護理部

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
心導管(cardiac catheterization)是目前在國內外診斷及治療冠狀動脈疾病中最常見的檢查。經由股動脈部位進行侵入性穿刺且術後需抗凝血劑使用,相較於橈動脈有較高風險產生相關血管合併症(出血、血腫)為最常見。為避免此血管合併症產生,只要股動脈執行心導管術後病人,不論有動脈鞘管留置或剛移除導管者,皆採長時間的平躺臥位並固定患肢,避免半坐臥姿勢造成上述合併症發生。然而,此限制性的常規措施,容易使病人抱怨身體不適、腰背疼痛並擔心進食嗆咳等,甚至無法讓肺部有效擴張及良好呼吸道通氣。故期望藉由實證文獻佐證方式,了解執行股動脈心導管術後病人予床頭抬高是否會增加血管相關合併症。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
本文運用實證步驟首先確立PICO問題,設定P:執行股動脈心導管術後病人、I:床頭抬高、C :平躺、O:血管合併症,運用PICO關鍵字、同義詞、MeSH term及Emtree,依搜尋策略以布林邏輯方式,以OR連集及AND交集,並應用切截字及過濾器進行資料庫檢索,包含:華藝線上圖書館、PubMed、Embase和CINHAL共四個資料庫搜尋相關文獻。文獻納入條件:發表於2015年至2020年之中英文文章、標題及摘要內容要符合PICO主題、可全文覽閱,因本文探討議題為介入性問題,故研究設計限制為隨機控制研究(Randomized Controlled Trails, RCTs)、系統性文獻回顧(Systematic Review, SR)、系統性文獻回顧及統合分析(Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, MA),共搜尋28篇文獻,經篩選符合條件為兩篇RCTs文獻。
文獻的品質評讀:
將兩篇RCTs文章以Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine 2011進行證據等級評估,證據等級皆為Level 2。兩篇文獻研究目的主要為探討經心導管術後予床頭搖高及改變姿勢是否會造成穿刺部位產生血管合併症(出血、血腫),研究結果顯示:不會產生血管合併症(出血、血腫)(P >0.05),且可促進舒適度、降低痠痛感、避免尿滯留、增加肺部擴張及降低不必要的吸入性肺炎。
結果、結論與建議:
綜合兩篇研究顯示:執行股動脈心導管術後病人予抬高床頭並不會造成血管相關合併症(出血、血腫),反而可增進病人舒適、減輕痠痛感、避免尿滯留、增加肺部擴張及降低不必要的吸入性肺炎。建議未來可針對執行股動脈心導管術後病人進行舒適度關懷,提供適切的擺位以緩解身體不適,並優先使用於非緊急心導管病人使用。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
Cardiac catheterization is currently the most common examination in the diagnosis and treatment of coronary artery disease worldwide. The puncture from the femoral artery has a higher risk than the radial artery, and it is prone to related vascular complications including hemorrhage and hematoma. In order to avoid vascular-related complications following cardiac catheterization in the femoral artery, the routine care were keeping a supine position and fixed the affected limb, and avoiding semi-sitting, regardless of whether the arterial sheath has been indwelled or the catheter has just been removed, causes the above-mentioned complications. However, such restrictive conventional measures easily lead to physical discomfort complains, such as back pain, coughing, and even though unable to effectively expand the lungs and keep good airway ventilation. This evidence-based researching aims to understand that is it at high risk of vascular-related complications by raising the head of the bed after patients undergoing femoral artery cardiac catheterization?
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
We started to search the PICO-related synonyms, MeSH term and Emtree in four databases including CEPS, PubMed, Embase and CINHAL. And then we used Bollinger logic principles OR、AND、filter to identify relevant peer-reviewed articles. We limited articles published between 2015 and 2020, the language in English and design in systematic review (SR), SR and meta-analysis (MA), and randomized controlled trails (RCTs). One RCT and one randomized-controlled quasi-experimental study were selected from a total of 28 articles, after screening, meet the conditions as two RCTs documents. The literature was reviewed by the 2020 CASP evaluation tool, and the level of evidence was evaluated by Oxford Centre for Evidence-based Medicine Levels of Evidence (2011).
Critical Appraisal:
The level of evidence of two studies are assigned to level II after CASP 2020 and Oxford Centre for Evidence-based Medicine Levels of Evidence (2011) critical appraisal. Two studies assessed does raise head of the bed and change posture can cause vascular-related complications following patients received cardiac catheterization. Studies have found that a gradually raise the head of the bed or change posture within eight hours of following cardiac catheterization, it not only can increase patients’ physical comfort, lower low back pain and urine retention, better lung expansion, and reduce unnecessary aspiration pneumonia. In addition, it does not increase the incidence of vascular-related complications (P>0.05).
Results, Conclusions and Recommendations:
After the process of evidence-based review, we found that raising the head of the bed following patients ongoing cardiac catheterization would not cause vascular-related complications. In the opposite, it can enhance patient comfort and reduce post-procedure bed rest pain. Suggested that the results of evidence-based search can be put to practice in the future.