耳穴位按壓是否能改善癌症病人接受化學治療引起的噁心感?Does auricular acupressure improve nausea in cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy?

1001 8 201

2023-10-23 已刊登
綜 整 預防/治療/介入類型

作  者

蔡歆妤 余慧筠* 李幸蓉 詹雅惠

文章類別

A 類:實證健康照護綜整

問題類型

治療/預防性問題

健康狀況

腫瘤醫學 (Oncology)  

治療/介入措施

生物行為相關措施(Bio-behavioral Intervention) - 耳穴位按壓

專長類別

腫瘤及安寧/緩和

中文關鍵詞

#耳穴位按壓 #癌症病人 #化學治療 #噁心感

英文關鍵詞

#auricular acupressure # cancer patient # chemotherapy # nausea

機構名稱

臺北榮民總醫院

申請單位

護理部C069

中文摘要

形成臨床提問:
噁心嘔吐是化學治療常見的副作用,在臨床照護中病人會因噁心感導致不想進食,嚴重時會造成脫水、電解質不平衡,甚至降低對化學治療的配合度。臨床上常使用藥物緩解症狀,但卻有相關副作用如低血壓、頭痛、便秘和眩暈等,搜尋文獻發現耳穴位按壓為近來新興穴位療法,被用來管理各種健康狀況,故引發筆者進一步探討耳穴位按壓是否能改善癌症病人接受化學治療引起的噁心感。
文獻搜尋的方法與分析:
依實證步驟確立PICO:耳穴位按壓是否能改善癌症病人接受化學治療引起的噁心感,使用MeSH term找出同義字增加搜尋廣度,關鍵字設定:P (Chemotherapies、Cancer patient、Chemotherapy、Pharmacotherapy、Drug Therapies、Neoplasm)、I (Auricular acupressure、Auricular acupoint)、O (Nausea、Nauseating、Emesis),搜尋五個電子資料庫,包括Cochrane、PubMed、CINAHL、Medline(ProQuest)、CEPS華藝中文電子期刊,依循布林邏輯將關鍵字用OR和AND做聯集與交集,並列舉搜尋條件包含五年內文獻(2018-2022年)、人類,文獻研究類型限系統性文獻統合分析(Systematic Review, SR)及隨機對照試驗研究(Randomized Controlled Trial, RCT),語言限中、英文,最終選定1篇SR、2篇RCT進行評析。
文獻的品質評讀:
使用牛津大學(University of Oxford)發展之系統性文獻回顧與統合分析之文獻評析表(Systematic Review Appraisal Sheet, 2005)、隨機對照研究之文獻評析表(RCT Critical Appraisal Sheet, 2010)為評讀工具;證據等級則依據牛津實證醫學中心證據等級表(OCEBM Levels of Evidence Working Group, 2011) ,評讀三篇文獻證據等級SR文獻為Level 1、2篇RCT文獻皆為Level 2。
結果、結論與建議:
1.SR文獻:耳穴位按壓有助於延遲化療引起的噁心及降低止吐藥相關不良反應,且對於整體的噁心感是有治療效果,但單獨接受耳穴位按壓或耳穴位按壓與藥物同時使用對急性噁心感較沒影響。 2.RCT文獻1:耳穴位按壓對於化學治療引起的急性噁心發生率及嚴重度顯著低於單獨使用止吐藥。 3.RCT文獻2:耳穴位按壓對於化學治療病人的總體生活品質相關中的噁心感是可以緩解的。 綜整三篇文章顯示耳穴按壓對於化學治療引起延遲性的噁心程度,以及對於整體性的噁心程度是有顯著改善效果,可減少噁心感發生的頻率、強度及帶來的不適程度,使病人生活品質更加提升。然而耳穴位因為較小和不易定位,需使用vaccaria seeds等器材附著在穴位上以確保穴位位置的正確性,運用在臨床上需考慮到穴位按壓之正確性,其執行率也較難以計算,若病人無法配合也將影響成效,因此若要將穴位按壓廣泛推廣到臨床照護,其按壓時間、頻率、穴位貼更換頻率、實施者資質等方面存在差異,穴位按壓的持續性及執行率也需研討相關措施以達到期望效果,建議未來建構標準化流程使運用在臨床上可以更加統一和規範。

英文摘要

Ask an answerable question (PICO):
Nausea and vomiting are common side effects of chemotherapy. In clinical care, it will cause the patient do not want to eat. Then the patient will be dehydrated, electrolyte imbalance, and even reduce the cooperation with chemotherapy. Although antiemetic is often used to relieve symptoms, but related side effects such as hypotension, headache, constipation, and dizziness. Literature review found the acupuncture is a newly acupoint therapy, which arouse the author to explore whether auricular acupressure can improve nausea caused by cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy.
The Method and Analysis of Literature Review:
According to the evidence process form the PICO question: Does auricular acupressure improve nausea in cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy. To increasing the breadth of search , using Cochrane and PubMed to find synonyms and MeSH terms. The key words set: P (Chemotherapies, Cancer patient, Chemotherapy, Pharmacotherapy, Drug Therapies, Neoplasm), I (Auricular acupressure, Auricular acupoint), O (Nausea, Nauseating, Emesis). Search five electronic databases, including Cochrane, PubMed, CINAHL, Medline(ProQuest), and CEPS Huayi Chinese electronic databases, using Boolean logic to union (OR), intersection (AND), and list the search criteria including: within five years literatures (2018-2022), human, literature type limited to Systematic Review (SR), or randomized Controlled Trial (RCT), Language is limited to Chinese and English. Finally, 1 SR and 2 RCT are enrolled for appraisal and analysis.
Critical Appraisal:
The systematic review appraisal sheet 2005 and RCT critical appraisal sheet 2010 were used to appraise the literature of SR and RCT respectively which developed by the University of Oxford. The evidence level is divided into Level 1, Level 2, and Level 2 based on the Oxford Center for Empirical Medicine levels of Evidence 2011.
Results, Conclusions and Recommendations:
1.Auricular acupressure can help to delay chemotherapy-induced nausea and reduce antiemetic drug-related adverse reactions, and it has a therapeutic effect on overall nausea. However, auricular acupressure alone or combined with drugs is less effective for acute nausea. 2.Compared with antiemetics alone, auricular acupressure significantly reduces the incidence and severity of chemotherapy-induced acute nausea. 3.Auricular acupressure can alleviate nausea related to the overall quality of life of cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy. In conclusion, the three articles show that auricular acupressure has a significantly improved effect on the delayed chemotherapy-induced nausea relief efficiency and overall nausea, can reduce the frequency, intensity and degree of discomfort caused by chemotherapy-induced nausea so that improving the quality of life of patients. It is worth translated the evidence reports of auricular acupressure into clinical practice on the relief of chemotherapy-induced nausea to be adjunctive measures. However, auricular point is relatively small and precise that need to use the equipment such as vaccaria seeds which need to be attached to the auricular points to keep pressing on the correct acupuncture points. In clinical practice, the accuracy of acupoint pressing and the patient cooperation must be considered, and the executive rate is difficult to calculate. Therefore, if auricular acupressure is to be widely used in the care of cancer patients, there are differences in the pressing time, frequency, replacement frequency of acupoint patches, and the qualifications of the implementers. In addition, the continuity and executive rate need to be further studied. In order to achieve the desired effect, it is recommended to construct a standardized process in the future so that the clinical application can be more unified and standardized.